Brinks and SimpliSafe sit on opposite sides of the home security spectrum. Brinks is an old-school brand that pairs professional installation with 36-month contracts. SimpliSafe is the poster child for contract-free DIY. Both monitor your home 24/7 — but the cost structure, equipment ownership, and flexibility are very different.
Quick Comparison: Brinks vs SimpliSafe
| Feature | Brinks | SimpliSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $29.99–$39.99 | $0–$27.99 |
| Contract | 36 months | None |
| Installation | Professional (included) | DIY (15–45 min) |
| Equipment Cost | $0 upfront (leased) or $199–$599 (owned) | $199–$660 |
| Cameras | Indoor, outdoor, doorbell (Alarm.com) | 4 models (proprietary) |
| Smart Home | Alarm.com (Z-Wave, Alexa, Google) | Alexa, Google (no Z-Wave) |
| HomeKit | No | No |
| Platform | Alarm.com | Proprietary |
| Video Verification | Yes (Alarm.com) | Live Guard ($9.99 add-on) |
| Cellular Backup | All plans | Paid plans only |
The Contract Problem
Brinks requires a 36-month contract. Cancel early and you owe the remaining balance — potentially $720–$1,080 in termination fees. SimpliSafe has zero contracts. Cancel any month, no penalty, no questions.
This matters more than most people realize. Moving, changing financial situations, or just wanting to switch systems — a 3-year commitment locks you in regardless.
Monthly Plans Compared
| Tier | Brinks | SimpliSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Self-Monitor | Not available | $0/mo (app alerts only) |
| Basic | $29.99/mo (Home Complete) | $19.99/mo (Standard) |
| Premium | $39.99/mo (Home Complete + Video) | $27.99/mo (Interactive) |
SimpliSafe undercuts Brinks by $10–$12/month at every tier. And SimpliSafe has a free self-monitoring option that Brinks doesn’t offer at all.
Equipment and Installation
Brinks offers free equipment on contract plans (you’re leasing it — it stays with Brinks if you cancel). Buying equipment outright runs $199–$599. Professional installation is included, which is the main draw for non-DIY buyers.
SimpliSafe is fully DIY. Kits cost $199–$660 but you own everything outright. Setup takes 15–45 minutes with peel-and-stick sensors. No technician visit, no appointment windows.
Cameras
Brinks uses Alarm.com cameras, which are mature and reliable. Indoor, outdoor, and doorbell options. Video verification through Alarm.com’s platform is one of the best in the industry — dispatchers can view clips to confirm real emergencies.
SimpliSafe has 4 proprietary cameras: indoor SimpliCam ($99), Outdoor Camera ($170), Video Doorbell Pro ($169), and Wireless Outdoor Camera ($250). Quality is decent but not class-leading. Live Guard video verification costs an extra $9.99/month on top of monitoring.
Smart Home Integration
Brinks wins here through Alarm.com. Z-Wave device support means smart locks, lights, thermostats, and garage door openers all integrate natively. Automation rules are flexible and reliable.
SimpliSafe’s smart home support is limited to Alexa and Google Assistant voice commands. No Z-Wave, no Zigbee, no native third-party device control. For a smart home-focused setup, SimpliSafe falls short.
3-Year Total Cost Comparison
| Scenario | Brinks | SimpliSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Self-Monitor | Not available | $249 kit + $0 = $249 |
| Basic Monitoring | $0 equip + $1,080 = $1,080 | $249 + $720 = $969 |
| Premium + Video | $0 equip + $1,440 = $1,440 | $249 + $1,008 = $1,257 |
SimpliSafe is cheaper in every monitored scenario. And the self-monitor option ($249 total over 3 years) is something Brinks cannot match at any price.
Where Each System Wins
Pick Brinks if you:
- Want professional installation and don’t want to DIY
- Need Alarm.com’s smart home ecosystem (Z-Wave devices, automations)
- Want video verification included in your plan (no add-on fee)
- Don’t mind a 36-month commitment
Pick SimpliSafe if you:
- Refuse contracts and want monthly flexibility
- Want a free self-monitoring option
- Prefer DIY setup at your own pace
- Want lower monthly costs
The System Neither Mentions
Both Brinks and SimpliSafe lack HomeKit support. Neither offers a free smart home hub. Abode gives you no contracts, a $0/month self-monitoring tier, and a gateway that works with Z-Wave, Zigbee, HomeKit, Alexa, and Google — the smart home flexibility of Brinks with the contract freedom of SimpliSafe. A $200 Abode kit with free monitoring costs $200 over 3 years.
Related: Abode vs SimpliSafe | ADT vs SimpliSafe | Brinks vs eufy
Verdict
SimpliSafe beats Brinks for most buyers. No contract, lower monthly cost, free self-monitoring, and solid enough cameras. Brinks only makes sense if you specifically want professional installation and Alarm.com’s device ecosystem — and are willing to pay a $200–$500 premium over 3 years for it.
If neither quite fits, look at Abode. It fills the smart home gap both leave open, with no contracts and the lowest 3-year cost of the three.
Related Brinks and SimpliSafe Alternatives
With over 20 years of experience evaluating home security technologies, Andrew is a trusted home security expert. He specializes in DIY home security systems, indoor and outdoor security cameras, doorbell cameras, and safety software such as password managers. Andrew uses in-depth research to provide accurate and actionable insights. His work helps you make better decisions to protect your home.
Leave a Reply