Vivint and eufy are not really competitors — they solve completely different problems. Vivint is a full smart home security platform with professional monitoring, pro installation, and proprietary hardware. eufy is a camera brand that stores footage locally and charges nothing monthly. Comparing them only makes sense if you are deciding between a monitored alarm system and a standalone camera setup.
Here is the honest breakdown of what each offers, what each costs over 3 years, and which approach actually protects your home.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Vivint | eufy |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $44.99/mo | $0 |
| Equipment | $0 down (60-mo finance) | $60–$500 (buy outright) |
| Contract | 60 months (equipment loan) | None |
| Professional Monitoring | 24/7 with police dispatch | No |
| Installation | Professional | DIY |
| Cameras | Indoor, outdoor, doorbell | Indoor, outdoor, doorbell, floodlight, PTZ |
| Door/Window Sensors | Yes | No |
| Alarm Siren | Yes | Camera sirens only |
| Smart Home Hub | Yes (Vivint panel) | HomeBase 3 (limited) |
| HomeKit | No | Limited (live view only) |
| Cloud Storage | Included in plan | Not needed (local storage) |
| Video Storage | Cloud (30 days) | Local on HomeBase / microSD |
3-Year Cost: The Gap Is Massive
| Setup | Equipment | Monthly (36 mo) | 3-Year Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vivint Smart Home | $0 down* | $1,620 | $1,620+ |
| Vivint + Cameras | $0 down* | $1,620 | $2,200+ |
| eufy 3-Camera Setup | $400–$600 | $0 | $400–$600 |
| eufy Full Setup (5 cameras + HomeBase) | $800–$1,000 | $0 | $800–$1,000 |
*Vivint finances equipment over 60 months. Even if you “own” it after year 5, the monitoring contract continues. Cancel early and you owe the remaining equipment balance.
eufy costs 1/3 to 1/2 of Vivint over 3 years. But you get cameras and nothing else — no monitoring, no sensors, no alarm panel, no dispatch.
Where Vivint Wins
- Real security system: Door/window sensors, motion detectors, glass break sensors, alarm siren, 24/7 monitoring with police/fire dispatch.
- Smart home control: The Vivint panel controls locks, thermostats, lights, and garage doors. One app for everything.
- Professional installation: A tech installs sensors, cameras, and smart devices. No DIY headaches.
- Cloud storage included: 30 days of video recording in the plan. No microSD cards to manage.
Where eufy Wins
- Zero monthly fees: Buy cameras once, pay nothing ongoing. Ever.
- Local storage: Footage stays on your HomeBase or microSD card. No cloud, no data breach risk, no subscription gatekeeping.
- Camera quality: eufy’s S350 dual-lens cameras (4K + 2K telephoto) match or beat Vivint’s cameras at half the price.
- No contract: Nothing to cancel, no early termination fees, no 60-month equipment loans.
- Privacy: All AI processing happens locally on the HomeBase. eufy doesn’t route your footage through their servers (post-2023 privacy fix).
The Real Question: Do You Need Monitoring?
This is the core decision. eufy gives you video surveillance — you see what happens and get alerts on your phone. But if someone breaks in at 3 AM while you are sleeping, eufy records it. That is all. No one calls the police. No siren scares the intruder off (unless they are near a camera with a built-in speaker).
Vivint dispatches police, fire, or medical within seconds of a triggered alarm. You have door/window sensors covering entry points, a loud siren, and a monitoring center watching 24/7. That is real security.
Cameras alone are not a security system. They are evidence collectors.
The Middle Ground: Abode + eufy Cameras
You don’t have to choose between $45/month Vivint and cameras-only eufy. Abode offers a $0/month free tier with a real alarm system: sensors, siren, Z-Wave/Zigbee smart home hub, HomeKit support. Add pro monitoring for $6/month.
Pair Abode with eufy cameras and you get:
- Real alarm system with door/window sensors: $200 (Abode kit)
- 3 eufy cameras: $400–$600
- Optional monitoring: $6/month ($216 over 3 years)
- 3-year total: $600–$1,016
That is half of Vivint’s cost with better cameras, real monitoring, and HomeKit support. No 60-month contract.
Read more: Abode vs Vivint | eufy vs Ring | Reolink vs eufy
Verdict
Pick Vivint if: You want a fully installed smart home + security system and do not mind paying $45/month for 5+ years. Best for people who value convenience over cost.
Pick eufy if: You only need cameras for video surveillance and refuse to pay monthly fees. Accept that cameras alone don’t call the police.
Pick Abode + eufy if: You want a real alarm system, great cameras, smart home control, and HomeKit — at half the cost of Vivint with no long-term contract.
With over 20 years of experience evaluating home security technologies, Andrew is a trusted home security expert. He specializes in DIY home security systems, indoor and outdoor security cameras, doorbell cameras, and safety software such as password managers. Andrew uses in-depth research to provide accurate and actionable insights. His work helps you make better decisions to protect your home.
Leave a Reply