Vivint and SimpliSafe sit at opposite ends of the home security market. Vivint is the premium smart-home-plus-security play — professionally installed, $45+/month, long contracts, and a full smart home platform with doorbell cameras, smart locks, and a proprietary panel. SimpliSafe is the budget DIY counter — self-install in 30 minutes, no contract, $0–$28/month, and equipment you own outright.
The question isn’t which is “better.” It’s whether you want to pay 2–3x more for professional installation and a smart home ecosystem, or save $1,000+ over 3 years with a simpler system you set up yourself. Here’s the full breakdown.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Vivint | SimpliSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $44.99–$54.99 | $0–$27.99 |
| Contract | 60 months (financing) or month-to-month | None |
| Equipment Cost | $599–$2,000+ (financed or upfront) | $199–$509 (own outright) |
| Installation | Professional (included) | DIY (30 min) |
| Monitoring | 24/7 professional (required) | Self-monitor free, pro from $19.99/mo |
| Smart Home | Full platform (locks, lights, thermostat, garage) | Limited (Alexa/Google voice only) |
| HomeKit | ❌ | ❌ |
| Cameras | Indoor, outdoor, doorbell (proprietary) | Indoor, outdoor, doorbell (SimpliSafe brand) |
| App Rating | 4.2★ (iOS) | 4.6★ (iOS) |
| BBB Rating | B+ | A+ |
Where Vivint Wins
- Full smart home integration: Vivint’s panel controls Z-Wave locks, lights, thermostats, and garage doors natively. SimpliSafe has almost zero smart home capability beyond Alexa/Google voice arm/disarm.
- Professional installation: A tech comes to your home, installs everything optimally, programs the system, and walks you through it. Good for people who don’t want to touch a drill.
- Better cameras: Vivint’s Outdoor Camera Pro has 4K HDR, package detection, and “lurker detection” that warns people on your property before they do anything. SimpliSafe cameras are fine but basic.
- Smart home panel: The Vivint Smart Hub is a 7″ touchscreen that doubles as a smart home controller. SimpliSafe’s keypad is just an arm/disarm device.
Where SimpliSafe Wins
- Price — by a lot: SimpliSafe’s 3-year cost is $199–$1,207. Vivint’s is $1,619–$4,979. That’s not a typo.
- No contract: Cancel anytime, no penalty. Vivint’s equipment financing locks you into 60 months of payments.
- Self-monitoring for free: SimpliSafe lets you use the full system with real-time alerts, no monthly fee. Vivint requires a paid plan to use your own equipment.
- Own your equipment: SimpliSafe gear is yours. If Vivint finances your equipment and you cancel early, you still owe the balance.
- Better reputation: SimpliSafe has an A+ BBB rating. Vivint has a B+ with more complaints per customer about billing, contracts, and cancellation.
3-Year Cost Comparison
| Scenario | Vivint | SimpliSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment | $599–$2,000 | $199–$509 |
| Monthly × 36 | $1,620 ($45/mo) | $0 (self) – $1,008 ($28/mo) |
| 3-Year Total | $2,219–$3,620 | $199–$1,517 |
| Savings vs Vivint | — | $702–$3,421 |
Even comparing Vivint’s cheapest setup against SimpliSafe’s most expensive, SimpliSafe saves you at least $700 over 3 years. At the extremes, the gap is over $3,400.
Who Should Pick Vivint
- You want a full smart home platform (lights, locks, thermostat, garage) managed from one panel
- You don’t want to install anything yourself
- Budget isn’t the primary factor — you’re optimizing for features and convenience
- You want top-tier outdoor cameras with AI detection
Who Should Pick SimpliSafe
- You want a straightforward alarm system without paying $45+/month
- No contracts — period
- You’re comfortable with a 30-minute DIY install
- You want the option to self-monitor for free
- Budget matters and you don’t need smart home integration
The Better Alternative: Abode
Neither Vivint nor SimpliSafe supports HomeKit, and SimpliSafe’s smart home integration is weak. Abode fills the gap between them:
| Feature | Vivint | SimpliSafe | Abode |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $44.99+ | $0–$27.99 | $0–$20 |
| Contract | 60-month financing | None | None |
| Smart Home | Full (Z-Wave) | Minimal | Full (HomeKit, Z-Wave, Zigbee, Matter) |
| HomeKit | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ |
| Self-Monitoring | ❌ | ✅ Free | ✅ Free |
| Pro Monitoring | $44.99/mo | $19.99–$27.99/mo | $20/mo |
| 3-Year Total | $2,219–$3,620 | $199–$1,517 | $199–$999 |
Abode gives you SimpliSafe’s price point with Vivint-level smart home integration — and adds HomeKit, which neither competitor offers. The Smart Security Kit ($199) with the Connect+ plan ($12/mo) gets you professional monitoring, Z-Wave/Zigbee device control, and Apple Home integration for $631 over 3 years. That’s less than half of Vivint’s cheapest option.
FAQs
Is Vivint worth the extra cost over SimpliSafe?
Only if you specifically want professional installation and a deep smart home platform (locks, lights, thermostat from one panel). If you just need a reliable alarm system, SimpliSafe or Abode delivers 90% of the security at half the cost.
Can I cancel Vivint early?
You can cancel the monitoring plan, but if you financed equipment, you still owe the remaining balance. This effectively acts as a contract even though Vivint markets “no long-term contracts.”
Does SimpliSafe work with smart home devices?
Barely. You can arm/disarm via Alexa or Google voice commands, and there’s a basic August lock integration. But there’s no Z-Wave, no Zigbee, no HomeKit, and no automation engine. For real smart home integration with a security system, look at Abode.
Which has better customer support?
SimpliSafe consistently ranks higher in customer satisfaction surveys and has an A+ BBB rating vs Vivint’s B+. Vivint complaints often center on billing disputes and cancellation difficulty.
Related Comparisons
Vivint Comparisons
- Vivint vs Wyze 2026 — $45/month smart home vs $3/month cameras
- Vivint vs ADT 2026 — Two premium pro-install brands head-to-head
- Vivint vs Ring 2026 — Premium pro-install vs Amazon DIY ecosystem
- Nest vs Vivint 2026 — Google cameras vs premium pro-install
SimpliSafe Comparisons
- Abode vs SimpliSafe 2026 — Smart home leader vs mainstream DIY
- SimpliSafe vs ADT 2026 — Budget DIY vs legacy pro monitoring
- Ring vs SimpliSafe 2026 — Amazon cameras vs budget alarm
- SimpliSafe vs Wyze 2026 — DIY alarm vs ultra-budget cameras
- SimpliSafe vs Cove 2026 — Two budget alarms compared
Better Alternatives
- Abode vs ADT 2026 — No-contract DIY vs legacy brand
- Abode vs Blink 2026 — Full alarm vs budget cameras
Buying Guides
- Best Home Security With No Monthly Fee — $0/month systems
- How to Choose a Home Security System — Complete buyer’s guide
- Smart Home Security Devices 2026 — Best smart gear this year
Last updated: March 2026
With over 20 years of experience evaluating home security technologies, Andrew is a trusted home security expert. He specializes in DIY home security systems, indoor and outdoor security cameras, doorbell cameras, and safety software such as password managers. Andrew uses in-depth research to provide accurate and actionable insights. His work helps you make better decisions to protect your home.
Leave a Reply